As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure

Betty Crocker BC-2958CS 12-Inch Electric Pizza Maker Review (2026)

Latest update:

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.

The Betty Crocker BC-2958CS Pizza Maker Plus is an indoor countertop appliance, not an outdoor oven: a 1440W electric clamshell with nonstick plates that bakes 12-inch pizzas from both sides on the kitchen counter. Betty Crocker pitches it as a general griddle too, for quesadillas, tortillas, pancakes, panini, crepes, s'mores and giant cookies. It weighs 5.5 lb and the size fields read 15.9 x 13.8 x 5 in, so it stores in a cupboard. This listing is the silver finish; the BC-2958CR is the same maker in red. Our verdict: a cheap, handy kitchen gadget for quick thin-crust pizzas and snacks when you don't want to heat the oven. It will not give a charred, airy crust like a stone oven, and the listing gives no temperature or thermostat setting. The listing also notes it cannot ship to several US states (including Colorado, Illinois, Maine, Minnesota and Vermont) under PFAS rules, which points to the nonstick coating. Based on Betty Crocker's listing, not on hands-on testing.

What stands out

  • 1440W indoor clamshell
  • 12-inch nonstick plates
  • 5.5 lb, cupboard-size
  • Doubles as a griddle and panini press

Who it fits

Good fit for

Households that want quick 12-inch pizzas, quesadillas or panini on the kitchen counter without turning on the big oven.

Who should skip it

Anyone after a stone-baked or wood-fired crust, buyers avoiding PFAS nonstick coatings, and people who want a temperature dial.

Verdict: A low-cost countertop pizza and snack maker, not a pizza oven.

Betty Crocker BC-2958CS: listed specs

BC-2958CS power: 1440W

Plugs into a kitchen outlet.

BC-2958CS cooking size: 12-inch pizza

Nonstick top and bottom plates.

BC-2958CS weight: 5.5 lb

Size fields 15.9 x 13.8 x 5 in.

BC-2958CS finish: silver

BC-2958CR is the red version.

BC-2958CS shipping note: not sold in 9 US states

PFAS rules; temperature not listed.

How the Betty Crocker BC-2958CS is built

The BC-2958CS is a round clamshell: a heated lower plate holds the pizza and a heated lid closes over it, both with nonstick surfaces. There is no stone, no flame and no oven chamber, so the crust cooks by contact with the plate. The body is silver, light enough to lift with one hand, and flat enough to store on a shelf.

Using the Betty Crocker BC-2958CS in the kitchen

Plug it in on a clear counter, let the plates heat, lay a 12-inch crust with toppings on the lower plate and close the lid; thin crusts and flatbreads suit it best. Between pizzas, use it for quesadillas, grilled cheese or pancakes. Clean the plates by hand once cool, and avoid metal utensils on the nonstick surface.

Before you buy the Betty Crocker BC-2958CS

Choose the BC-2958CS if you want a cheap counter appliance for thin pizzas and snacks; choose a stone countertop oven or an outdoor pizza oven if crust char and rise matter to you.

Check before you buy

  • BC-2958CS is indoor, contact-cooked
  • No temperature control listed
  • Not shipped to 9 US states (PFAS)
  • Hand wash only

The product at a glance

Betty Crocker 12-Inch Electric Pizza Maker

Best for: Quick kitchen pizzas

Fuel Type
Electric
Maximum Pizza Size
12"
Heat Output
1440W
Placement
Indoor
Compatible Appliance
Griddle
Dimensions
15.9 × 13.8 × 5 inches

View on Amazon: Betty Crocker 12-Inch Electric Pizza Maker Affiliate link

Betty Crocker BC-2958CS Pizza Maker Plus (silver): 1440W indoor clamshell for 12-inch pizzas, nonstick plates, doubles as griddle and panini press, 5.5 lb.

Pros

  • BC-2958CS is cheap and light
  • Doubles as a panini press
  • No big oven to heat

Cons

  • BC-2958CS has no stone or char
  • No temperature setting listed
  • PFAS shipping limits

Good fit if

  • You want thin pizzas on the counter
  • You need a quesadilla and panini maker too

Skip if

  • You want a blistered, airy crust
  • You avoid PFAS cookware

Verdict: A handy counter gadget for thin pizzas and snacks.

Specifications side by side

Spec Betty Crocker 12-Inch Electric Pizza Maker
Fuel Type Electric
Maximum Pizza Size 12"
Heat Output 1440W
Placement Indoor
Pizza Size 12 Inch
Compatible Appliance Griddle
Dimensions 15.9 × 13.8 × 5 inches
Weight 5.5 pounds
Size Full Size
Color Silver
Model BC-2958CS

Frequently asked questions

Is the Betty Crocker BC-2958CS an outdoor pizza oven?

No, it is a 1440W indoor countertop pizza maker and grill.

What size pizza fits the Betty Crocker BC-2958CS?

A 12-inch pizza.

What else can the Betty Crocker BC-2958CS cook?

Quesadillas, tortillas, pancakes, panini, crepes, s'mores and giant cookies, per the listing.

How heavy is the Betty Crocker BC-2958CS?

5.5 lb.

Why can't the Betty Crocker BC-2958CS ship to some states?

The listing says it is not sold in Colorado, Connecticut, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, New Mexico, Rhode Island and Vermont, a PFAS restriction.

See also